Which withdrawal rule would have held?
Living off a portfolio takes a rule: the same amount every year, or more in good years and less in bad ones? The tool runs every past retirement year on its own and shows what three rules would have made of the same portfolio.
Free during the beta, no ads and no subscription. Once you sign in, this page opens the tool.
How it works
The fixed withdrawal pays the same amount in today's purchasing power every year, as in the well-known 4% rule. It is predictable but does not react to bad years: if the portfolio falls right at the start, the withdrawals eat it up. This sequence risk hits retirement years very differently.
Flexible rules adjust the withdrawal. With guardrails it drops by a fixed step once the withdrawal rate is well above its starting value, and rises again when the portfolio has done well. The “percentage of portfolio” rule pays the same share of the current portfolio every year, with a ceiling and a floor around the first withdrawal.
How to read the result: “The money lasted” counts the retirement years in which the rule could pay in full every year. The lowest annual withdrawal and the share of years with a cut show the price of flexibility. The final wealth shows how much was left in the typical retirement year. No rule is better at everything: more safety costs variation in income.
What a result looks like
Sample dataMade-up sample data, no market prices and no recommendation. Calculated with the same methods as the tool itself.
Inputs in this example
Locked: you can't change the inputs in the preview.
Run your own numbers with a free account Your own inputs, up-to-date data and every setting.
Create accountGuardrails. Starts like the fixed withdrawal. If the withdrawal rate (withdrawal divided by portfolio value) rises above 1.2 times its starting value, the withdrawal is cut by 10%; if it falls below 0.8 times, it rises by 10%.
Wealth by retirement year
Each line is a start year, in today's purchasing power.
Withdrawal per year
What the rule paid out, in today's purchasing power.
The rules compared
The same 41 retirement years (starting 1956 to 1996), the same portfolio.
| Rule | Money lasted | Lowest withdrawal | Average withdrawal | Years with a cut | Final wealth |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fixed, with inflation | 30 of 41 | $0 | $23,257 | 4% | $164,373 |
| Guardrails | 41 of 41 | $9,298 | $21,350 | 60% | $401,000 |
| 4.0% of the portfolio, with limits | 41 of 41 | $19,200 | $22,459 | 63% | $262,950 |
Years with a cut: share of years in which the withdrawal was below that of the first year. Final wealth: median after 30 years.
The hardest retirement years
With the selected rule (Guardrails): first the retirement years in which the money ran out, then those with the lowest payouts.
- Retirement start 1969$399,263 left at the endlowest withdrawal $9,298
- Retirement start 1973$308,014 left at the endlowest withdrawal $10,331
- Retirement start 1996$231,412 left at the endlowest withdrawal $10,228
- Retirement start 1972$406,584 left at the endlowest withdrawal $11,479
- Retirement start 1970$548,496 left at the endlowest withdrawal $11,479
One withdrawal at the start of each year; the rest stays invested for the whole year.
All amounts in today's purchasing power, without taxes. The past holds only a few independent periods of 30 years; the retirement years overlap.
Assumptions: Annual returns of the portfolio are invented, 70 years with several slumps, in today's purchasing power. One withdrawal at the start of each year, without costs and taxes.
Frequently asked questions
What is the 4% rule?
A rule of thumb from US studies of the 1990s: withdrawing 4% of the portfolio in the first year and then adjusting the amount only for inflation mostly worked in the 30-year periods examined at the time. It is a look back at US data, not a promise for other markets or the future.
What are withdrawal guardrails?
Limits for the withdrawal rate, that is withdrawal divided by portfolio value. If it is well above its starting value, the withdrawal is cut; if it is well below, it is raised. The tool uses a simplified version of the rules by Guyton and Klinger.
Why does the order of returns matter?
Losses in the first years hit the portfolio when it is largest, and the withdrawals sell at low prices. Two retirement years with the same average return can therefore end very differently. That is why the tool shows every retirement year on its own.
Where does the data come from?
With an account the tool uses the prices of your securities and long asset class series, some going back decades. On this page the returns are invented.
Learn more in the knowledge base
Run it with your own portfolios
Create an account, confirm your email and use this tool with up-to-date prices and your own ETFs.
- Price
- Free during the beta
- Data
- Licensed prices; interest rates, inflation and factors from public sources
- Privacy
- Servers in the EU, no ads, tracking only with your consent
- Devices
- Computer and phone, everything saved in your account