Small caps and the size premium: are small stocks worth it?
Small caps are the smaller listed companies of a market. For a long time it was considered settled that they deliver more return than large stocks over time: the so-called size premium. Since its discovery more than 40 years ago, however, it has become weaker and less reliable. In this article we look at how the premium is measured, what research says about its disappearance and why the quality of small companies could make the difference.
What counts as a small cap
There is no fixed dollar threshold. Index providers sort the companies of a market by their free-float market value. The large and mid-sized companies form the standard index, which covers about 85% of the market; the next companies up to about 99% of the market form the small-cap segment (MSCI GIMI Methodology 2024). An index such as the MSCI World therefore contains no small caps, while an index with the suffix IMI (Investable Market Index) does.
Coverage according to MSCI's methodology (MSCI GIMI Methodology 2024), widths to scale.
Even smaller are micro caps, which often do not appear in the usual small-cap indexes at all. This distinction matters for research, because a large part of the historical size premium comes from the very smallest stocks, which are hard and expensive for investors to trade.
In the US, small caps roughly correspond to the companies in the common small-cap indexes of the major index providers; internationally, to the companies in small-cap indexes for individual countries or regions.
How the size premium is measured: SMB
The best-known measure comes from Fama and French. They split all stocks by size into small and big and additionally by valuation into value, neutral and growth. The SMB factor (Small Minus Big) is the average return of the three small portfolios minus that of the three big ones (Fama and French 1993):
Splitting by valuation means SMB compares small and big stocks of the same style. This prevents a value effect from showing up as a size effect. SMB is a long-short portfolio: its return is the premium itself, not the return of a small-cap ETF. Anyone who buys a small-cap ETF gets the market return plus the SMB premium plus everything else that distinguishes the ETF from the market.
What the research shows
Banz (1981) was the first to find that small companies earned higher returns than their market risk in the CAPM would suggest. Shortly afterward, Keim (1983) showed that a large part of this lead in US stocks falls in January, especially in its first trading days. Fama and French (1992) found that size and valuation explain differences between stock returns better than beta, and made SMB a factor of their three-factor model (Fama and French 1993).
Then came the doubts. In US data, the premium was hardly detectable after its discovery. van Dijk (2011) summarizes the discussion in a review: the size effect varies strongly over time and between countries, and it is open whether it compensates for risk or reflects errors in data and models. More generally, McLean and Pontiff (2016) show that many known return patterns weaken after they are published.
An influential answer comes from Asness et al. (2018). They show that the usual objections to the size premium disappear once you account for the quality of companies. Small stocks are more often “junk” on average: not very profitable, not very stable, highly indebted. Controlling for this produces a size premium that is stable over time, is not limited to micro caps and January, and shows up in many industries and international markets.
Why small stocks could deliver more
- Higher risk: Small companies are less diversified, depend more on the economy and fail more often. In severe crises they often fall more than large stocks.
- Lower liquidity: Small stocks trade less, and buying and selling costs more. Amihud (2002) showed that expected illiquidity goes along with higher expected returns, especially for small stocks.
- Less attention: Fewer analysts and fewer institutional investors follow small companies. Mispricings could persist longer.
- Room to grow: Successful small companies can multiply in size; large ones hardly can.
The first two reasons are risks for which investors could demand a premium. Then the premium would be permanent, but not free. The other two are opportunities for active investors and could disappear as more money flows into small stocks.
Advanced: size with quality
The idea of Asness and coauthors can be understood with a regression. You explain the SMB return with a quality factor QMJ (Quality Minus Junk), which buys profitable, stable companies and shorts weak ones (Asness et al. 2019):
- size premium not explained by quality
- sensitivity of SMB to quality; usually negative for small stocks
In practice this means: a small-cap portfolio that avoids unprofitable and highly indebted companies could capture the premium better than a broad small-cap index. Some index providers and fund companies implement exactly this with quality filters. Whether the premium holds in the future, however, not even this analysis can guarantee.
A second point concerns risk. Small caps have a beta to the overall market close to or above 1 and fluctuate more. A factor regression for a small-cap fund therefore typically shows a market beta around 1 and a clearly positive SMB loading. More in the article on Fama-French factors.
Small caps in a portfolio
If you hold a broad world index including small caps (IMI), you already own small companies at their market weight, about one seventh of the equity allocation. If you hold an index without small caps, you can add them with a separate small-cap ETF. About 85% standard index and 15% small caps roughly matches market weights; more small caps is a deliberate bet on the size premium.
- Diversification: Small caps add thousands of companies to the portfolio, but their prices move closely with large stocks. The diversification benefit is smaller than the number of companies suggests.
- Costs: Small-cap ETFs are usually more expensive than ETFs on large stocks, and trading costs inside the fund are higher.
- Patience: The premium can be negative for ten years and longer. If you overweight small caps, you need a rationale that still holds after a bad decade.
How an allocation would have affected return, volatility and maximum drawdown can be tried out in the backtest with the long asset class series.
Limits and common mistakes
- Confusing the historical premium with achievable returns: The early studies used micro caps that were barely tradable, and ignored trading costs.
- Overrating short periods: Five good or bad years for small caps say little about the premium.
- Mixing size and style: Small-cap indexes often contain more growth or more value stocks than the overall market. A comparison with large stocks then measures both at once.
- Survivorship bias: If you backtest small companies that are successful today, you do not see the many that did not make it. More in the article on survivorship bias.
How Portfolio Lab calculates
The Factors tool decomposes the return of a fund or portfolio with a regression on the Fama and French factors, including SMB. A positive SMB loading shows that a portfolio behaves like smaller companies; the factor statistics show the premiums by region over long periods. Under Asset classes there are long series by size and style, for the US from 1926 and for Europe from 1990, which can be used as building blocks in the Backtest.
How the regression is calculated, which factors are available for each region and how to read the results is described in the factors methodology.
Frequently asked questions
What are small caps?
The smaller listed companies of a market. Index providers count the companies that, after the large and mid-sized ones (about 85% of the market), cover up to about 99% of market capitalization.
Does the size premium still exist?
That is disputed. In US data it was weak for a long time after its discovery in the 1980s. Newer research finds a more stable premium when the quality of companies is taken into account. There is no guarantee for the future.
Should I add a small-cap ETF?
If you hold a world index without small caps, you can add them to cover the whole market; about 15% roughly matches the market weight. More is a deliberate bet on the size premium, with higher volatility and often higher costs.
What does SMB mean?
Small Minus Big: the return of small stocks minus the return of big stocks with the same valuation style, measured according to Fama and French. SMB is the size premium as a long-short portfolio.
Are small caps riskier?
Yes, they usually fluctuate more, often fall further in crises and are less liquid. Individual small companies also fail more often, which is cushioned by diversification in a broad index.
What is the difference between the MSCI World and the MSCI World IMI?
The MSCI World contains large and mid-sized companies of developed countries; the MSCI World IMI additionally contains small caps. The IMI thus covers almost the entire investable market.
Literature
- Amihud, Yakov (2002): Illiquidity and stock returns: cross-section and time-series effects. Journal of Financial Markets 5 (1), pp. 31–56. doi:10.1016/S1386-4181(01)00024-6
- Asness, Clifford; Frazzini, Andrea; Israel, Ronen; Moskowitz, Tobias J.; Pedersen, Lasse H. (2018): Size matters, if you control your junk. Journal of Financial Economics 129 (3), pp. 479–509. doi:10.1016/j.jfineco.2018.05.006
- Asness, Clifford S.; Frazzini, Andrea; Pedersen, Lasse Heje (2019): Quality minus junk. Review of Accounting Studies 24 (1), pp. 34–112. doi:10.1007/s11142-018-9470-2
- Banz, Rolf W. (1981): The relationship between return and market value of common stocks. Journal of Financial Economics 9 (1), pp. 3–18. doi:10.1016/0304-405x(81)90018-0
- Fama, Eugene F.; French, Kenneth R. (1992): The Cross-Section of Expected Stock Returns. The Journal of Finance 47 (2), pp. 427–465. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6261.1992.tb04398.x
- Fama, Eugene F.; French, Kenneth R. (1993): Common risk factors in the returns on stocks and bonds. Journal of Financial Economics 33 (1), pp. 3–56. doi:10.1016/0304-405x(93)90023-5
- Keim, Donald B. (1983): Size-related anomalies and stock return seasonality. Journal of Financial Economics 12 (1), pp. 13–32. doi:10.1016/0304-405X(83)90025-9
- McLean, R. David; Pontiff, Jeffrey (2016): Does Academic Research Destroy Stock Return Predictability?. The Journal of Finance 71 (1), pp. 5–32. doi:10.1111/jofi.12365
- MSCI Inc. (2024): MSCI Global Investable Market Indexes Methodology. MSCI, November 2024; accessed October 25, 2026. Source
- van Dijk, Mathijs A. (2011): Is size dead? A review of the size effect in equity returns. Journal of Banking & Finance 35 (12), pp. 3263–3274. doi:10.1016/j.jbankfin.2011.05.009
This article explains a method; it is not investment or tax advice. Worked examples are simplified and rounded. All terms in the glossary.