Roth conversions: what converting costs and when it pays off
A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA or 401(k) into a Roth account. You pay income tax on the converted amount now, and in exchange qualified withdrawals later are tax-free and the Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions. This article shows how the tax on a conversion is calculated with the 2026 brackets, how much fits into your current bracket, when converting beats waiting and which five-year rules apply afterwards.
What a Roth conversion is
Money in a traditional IRA or a pre-tax 401(k) has never been taxed. When you convert it to a Roth IRA, the converted amount is added to your taxable income for the year, as if you had withdrawn it, but it stays invested in the Roth account. There is no income limit for conversions, which is why high earners use them for the backdoor Roth. A conversion cannot be undone: since 2018 a conversion can no longer be recharacterized back to a traditional IRA (IRS Publication 590-A 2025).
If you made nondeductible contributions to any traditional, SEP or SIMPLE IRA, part of the conversion is tax-free. That part is not chosen freely: Form 8606 spreads your after-tax basis over all your IRA balances at year end, the so-called pro rata rule (IRS Publication 590-B 2025). A direct trustee-to-trustee conversion is not an early distribution, so the 10% additional tax for withdrawals before age 59½ does not apply to it (IRS Publication 590-A 2025).
How the tax on a conversion is calculated
The conversion counts as ordinary income on top of everything else you earn. The tax on it is therefore the difference between your total tax with the conversion and your total tax without it, and the conversion fills the brackets above your other taxable income. It does not count as net investment income, so it is not hit by the 3.8% NIIT itself, although the higher income can push other investment income above the NIIT threshold.
- federal tax from the 2026 brackets, plus state income tax where it applies
- income after deductions, without the conversion
If the same person had $100,000 of taxable income, the first $5,700 of the conversion would still be taxed at 22% ($1,254) and the remaining $14,300 at 24% ($3,432), for a federal tax of $4,686 or 23.43% on average. Crossing a bracket is not a disaster, because only the dollars above the threshold pay the higher rate. The chart shows how the average federal rate on a conversion rises with its size for the filer in the example.
2026 brackets for single filers: 22% up to $105,700, 24% up to $201,775, 32% above. The rate on the last dollar jumps; the average rises slowly.
Filling a bracket
A common plan is to convert just enough each year to reach the top of your current bracket. The gap is easy to compute: the upper limit of the bracket minus your taxable income after the conversion. Years with unusually low income are the classic opportunity, for example between retirement and the start of Social Security and required minimum distributions, which for most retirees begin at age 73 (IRS, required minimum distributions 2026). A series of smaller conversions spread over such years often costs less than one large conversion, or than the forced withdrawals later.
Taxable income is not the only number that moves. A conversion raises adjusted gross income, which can make more of your Social Security benefits taxable through provisional income, reduce health insurance subsidies, and raise Medicare premiums through IRMAA, which looks at your income from two years earlier (SSA POMS HI 01101.031 2025). These effects can make the true marginal cost of a conversion several points higher than the bracket rate.
When converting pays off
Converting wins if the tax rate you pay now is lower than the rate you would pay on the same money in retirement. With the tax withheld from the conversion itself and the same return in both accounts, the comparison is exact: both paths grow by the same factor, so the one with the lower tax rate ends up ahead. Paying the tax from a taxable account tilts the balance toward converting, because that money would otherwise sit in an account whose earnings are taxed every year. In effect, you move extra money into the tax-free account.
- growth factor of the IRA over the holding period, (1 + r)^n
- growth factor of the taxable account after annual tax, (1 + r × (1 − tax on its earnings))^n
The comparison depends on assumptions that nobody knows for sure: future tax law, your income in retirement, whether you move to another state, and how long the money stays invested. Converting also has benefits that a simple tax comparison misses. A Roth IRA has no required minimum distributions for the original owner (IRS Publication 590-B 2025), tax-free withdrawals do not raise your income in later years, and heirs inherit an account they can withdraw from without income tax.
The five-year rules
Two separate five-year clocks apply. The first is per conversion: if you withdraw converted money within five years, counting from January 1 of the year of the conversion, and you are younger than 59½, the taxable part of that withdrawal costs the 10% additional tax, even though it is not taxed again (IRS Publication 590-B 2025). The second clock decides whether earnings come out tax-free: a distribution is qualified only after five years from the first year you contributed to any Roth IRA and once you are 59½ (or in a few other cases such as disability).
Withdrawals follow a fixed order: first your regular Roth contributions, which are always tax-free and penalty-free, then converted amounts in the order of the conversions, and only then earnings (IRS Publication 590-B 2025). For someone over 59½ the first clock no longer matters, which is one reason conversions are popular in early retirement.
- Under 59½: keep each conversion in the account for five years, or have enough contributions in the account to cover what you take out.
- Over 59½: converted amounts can come out any time without the additional tax; earnings need the account's own five-year period.
- Withholding: tax withheld from a conversion is a distribution; under 59½ the 10% additional tax applies to it (IRS Topic 557 2026).
Timing and paperwork
A conversion belongs to the calendar year in which the money leaves the traditional account, so the deadline is December 31, not the April deadline for contributions. Because a conversion can no longer be reversed, many people convert late in the year once their income is clear. The tax is due with the year's return, and a large conversion can require estimated tax payments to avoid an underpayment penalty. The custodian reports the conversion on Form 1099-R, and you report it on Form 8606 and your Form 1040 (IRS Publication 590-A 2025).
Conversions also interact with investment decisions. Converting after a market decline moves more shares for the same tax. Assets with the highest expected growth gain the most from being in the Roth account, while the tax is the same for every dollar converted.
Common mistakes
- Converting so much that it crosses several brackets: a few smaller conversions over several years often cost less.
- Paying the tax from the IRA before 59½: the withheld part is an early distribution and less money ends up in the Roth.
- Ignoring the pro rata rule: nondeductible basis in one IRA does not make a conversion from another IRA tax-free.
- Forgetting the side effects: Medicare premiums, health insurance subsidies and the taxation of Social Security can all rise with a conversion.
- Withdrawing converted money too soon: under 59½ the five-year clock of each conversion applies.
- Assuming the state treats it like the IRS: some states exempt retirement income, others tax conversions like wages, and moving states can change the picture.
This article explains general rules as of 2026 and is not tax advice. Your full tax return, state rules and benefits can change the result; check current IRS guidance or ask a tax professional before converting.
Frequently asked questions
How much tax will I pay on a Roth conversion?
The converted amount is added to your taxable income and taxed at your ordinary rates, so the tax is the difference between your tax with and without the conversion. A single filer with $80,000 of taxable income pays 22% on a $20,000 conversion in 2026, $4,400 in federal tax, plus state income tax in most states.
Is there an income limit for Roth conversions?
No. Anyone with money in a traditional IRA or an eligible employer plan can convert, regardless of income. Only direct contributions to a Roth IRA are limited by income.
When is a Roth conversion worth it?
When your tax rate today is lower than the rate you expect on the same money in retirement, or roughly equal and you can pay the tax from a taxable account. Low-income years before Social Security and required minimum distributions are the classic time.
What is the five-year rule for Roth conversions?
Each conversion has its own five-year period starting January 1 of the conversion year. If you are under 59½ and withdraw converted money before it ends, the taxable part costs a 10% additional tax. A separate five-year period from your first Roth IRA contribution applies to tax-free earnings.
Can I undo a Roth conversion?
No. Since 2018 a conversion can no longer be recharacterized back to a traditional IRA, so many people wait until late in the year when their income is known.
Should I pay the conversion tax from the IRA?
Usually not. Paying from a taxable account keeps the full amount growing tax-free in the Roth. Under 59½, tax withheld from the conversion is also an early distribution that can cost an extra 10%.
Literature
- Illinois Department of Revenue (2026): Publication 120, Retirement Income. Illinois Department of Revenue; accessed November 10, 2026. Source
- Internal Revenue Service (2025): Publication 590-A (2025), Contributions to Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs). Internal Revenue Service. Source
- Internal Revenue Service (2025): Publication 590-B (2025), Distributions from Individual Retirement Arrangements (IRAs). Internal Revenue Service; accessed November 10, 2026. Source
- Internal Revenue Service (2025): Revenue Procedure 2025-32: inflation-adjusted items for 2026. Internal Revenue Bulletin 2025-45; accessed November 2, 2026. Source
- Internal Revenue Service (2026): Retirement topics: Required minimum distributions (RMDs). Internal Revenue Service, last reviewed April 8, 2026; accessed November 2, 2026. Source
- Internal Revenue Service (2026): Topic no. 557, Additional tax on early distributions from traditional and Roth IRAs. Internal Revenue Service, last reviewed October 26, 2026; accessed November 2, 2026. Source
- Social Security Administration (2025): Program Operations Manual System, HI 01101.031: Determining the Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA). Social Security Administration, TN 36 (12-25); accessed November 2, 2026. Source
This article explains a method; it is not investment or tax advice. Worked examples are simplified and rounded. All terms in the glossary.