Portfolio Lab

Hedging a portfolio with futures: how many contracts, what it costs, what remains

In depth8 min read · updated 22 November 2026 · 3 sources

If you want to hedge a portfolio with futures, you sell equity index futures instead of the stocks themselves. It is fast, cheap, and leaves the holdings untouched. Three things matter: the right number of contracts, the cash for margin and margin calls, and the remaining risk, which stays because the portfolio never moves exactly like the index.

Hedging without selling

A short future gains when the index falls and loses when it rises. If you hold a stock portfolio alongside it, gains and losses largely offset each other. The holdings stay in place: no tax on capital gains comes due, no dividend is lost, and nothing has to be bought back after the hedge ends. That is why funds use futures to reduce market risk for a few weeks, for example ahead of an election or until a reallocation is complete.

A future is an exchange-traded forward contract: buyer and seller agree today on a price for a day in the future. Gains and losses are settled every day, and both sides post margin. Hardly any money changes hands at the start; that is why a large amount can be hedged with little capital. Hull (2021) describes structure, settlement, and expiration in detail.

The number of contracts: portfolio value, beta, and contract value

A contract stands for a fixed amount per index point, the contract size. The value of a contract is contract size times price. For the hedge to match the portfolio's risk, what counts is not only its value but its beta to the index: if the portfolio fluctuates more than the index, it needs more contracts.

sensitivity of the portfolio to the index, from a regression of returns
value of one contract
Result for index moves: unhedged, 2 large and 22 micro contracts

Portfolio with beta 1.1 from the example, without basis risk, interest, and dividends. Two contracts leave one tenth of the risk open; 22 micro contracts hedge it fully on paper.

Sector futures or the broad index

A broad index future hedges what the portfolio has in common with the market. If it deviates strongly, for example with lots of technology and few banks, more risk remains. Sector futures help: you break the portfolio down into sectors and sell the matching contract for each sector. This lowers the remaining risk but has two catches. First, small sectors quickly amount to less than one contract and round to zero. Second, some sector futures are thinly traded; open interest, the number of open contracts, shows whether there is enough market. If you hold more than a small part of open interest, you move the price yourself when rolling.

A mix is often best: the large sectors through their own contracts, the rest through the broad index. Which combination lowers volatility the most can also be determined statistically, with a regression of the portfolio on the futures' underlyings. The minimum variance hedge ratio is the beta to each underlying.

What the hedge costs

  • Margin: the exchange requires an amount per contract, often a few percent of contract value. At 6% that would be $18,000 per large contract in the example, so $36,000 for two.
  • Margin calls: if the index rises, the short future loses money every day, and the cash has to be in the account the next day, even if the portfolio has gained by the same amount. For a 10% rise that is $60,000 in the example (two contracts at $300,000 each). If you do not keep this cash ready, you have to unwind the hedge at the worst moment.
  • Interest and dividends: the futures price is above the index by the interest until expiration minus expected dividends. At 4% interest and 1.5% dividends, that is about 37.5 points on 6,000 over three months. The seller earns this gap, because it shrinks to zero by expiration. A fully hedged portfolio therefore earns roughly the money market rate, not zero.
  • Rolling: futures expire, usually quarterly. At expiration the old contract is bought back and the next one sold. Each time, commission and the bid-ask spread apply, a few dollars per contract for large index futures.

Instead of selling futures, you can sell short an ETF on the index or buy an inverse ETF. The short sale costs a borrow fee (about 0.5% a year, $3,300 a year on $660,000 in the example) and often ties up half the amount as collateral. An inverse ETF charges ongoing fees (about 0.9% a year, $5,940 in the example) and drifts away from the multiple of the index return over longer periods, because it rebalances every day. For a hedge over weeks this is often acceptable, over years rarely.

Basis risk: why no hedge is perfect

The remaining risk has three sources. The portfolio does not move exactly like the index (choice of stocks, weights, currency). The beta is estimated and changes. And the number of contracts is rounded. On top of that comes the gap between the future and the index itself, which shifts with expectations for interest and dividends. Together this is called basis risk. If you hedge a portfolio held in another currency with US futures, you also carry the currency risk on the hedged amount.

Ederington (1979) set the standard: the best hedge ratio is the one with the lowest combined volatility of position and future, and effectiveness is measured by the share of variance the hedge removes. Figlewski (1984) showed for S&P 500 futures that broad portfolios can be hedged well with them, small ones or ones that deviate from the index much less so. A rule of thumb follows: the less a portfolio has in common with the index, the more important matching sector futures become, or a check of how much volatility the hedge would actually have removed in the past.

Common mistakes

  • Contracts by value instead of risk: if you only divide portfolio value by contract value, you underhedge a portfolio with a high beta.
  • Forgetting margin calls: the hedge only works as long as the cash for daily losses is there.
  • Overlooking currency: US futures hedge the dollar amount; an investor whose account is in another currency carries the currency risk on the hedge itself.
  • Missing expiration: without rolling, the hedge ends on expiration day.
  • Too little open interest: with thinly traded sector futures, each roll costs more than the more precise hedge brings.

How Portfolio Lab calculates

The Hedging page calculates the number of contracts, costs, and remaining risk for your portfolio: sector by sector through the funds' holdings, with a few futures through returns, with a single index future, or with an optimizer under limits. The list of contracts with open interest comes from the weekly report of the US regulator CFTC; you enter the futures prices yourself. Instead of futures, short sales of an ETF or inverse ETFs can also be calculated. All assumptions are in the methodology.

Frequently asked questions

How many futures do I need for my portfolio?

Portfolio value times beta to the index, divided by the value of one contract. A portfolio of $600,000 with a beta of 1.1 needs 2.2 contracts on paper at a contract value of $300,000; micro contracts at one tenth of the size match more closely.

What does hedging with futures cost?

Commission and the bid-ask spread when buying, selling, and rolling, plus cash tied up for margin and margin calls. The gap from interest and dividends in the futures price benefits the seller.

Can I hedge a portfolio held in another currency with US futures?

Yes, if it mainly holds US stocks. Then the currency risk remains: the futures hedge the dollar amount, not the exchange rate. For European stocks, European index futures are a better fit.

Is an inverse ETF a good alternative?

For short periods often yes, because it is easy to buy and requires no margin calls. Over months and years it drifts away from the expected result because of daily rebalancing and ongoing costs.

Why does my hedged portfolio still earn something?

Because the short future trades above the index and this gap shrinks until expiration. A fully hedged stock portfolio earns roughly the money market rate, minus costs.

Literature

  1. Ederington, Louis H. (1979): The Hedging Performance of the New Futures Markets. The Journal of Finance 34 (1), pp. 157-170. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6261.1979.tb02077.x
  2. Figlewski, Stephen (1984): Hedging Performance and Basis Risk in Stock Index Futures. The Journal of Finance 39 (3), pp. 657-669. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6261.1984.tb03654.x
  3. Hull, John C. (2021): Options, Futures, and Other Derivatives. Pearson, 11th edition (Global Edition).

Full bibliography

This article explains a method; it is not investment or tax advice. Worked examples are simplified and rounded. All terms in the glossary.