Covered call ETFs: where the high payout comes from and what it costs
Covered call ETFs hold stocks or an index and continuously sell call options on them. They pay out the premiums collected, often monthly and at a level far above any dividend yield. That sounds like income without a downside. In fact, they trade part of future price gains for certain income today. This article covers how the strategy works, where its return comes from and when it falls behind the index.
How a covered call works
In a covered call, the investor owns a stock or an index and at the same time sells a call option on it. The buyer of the option pays a premium for it. If the price rises above the strike price, the seller has to hand over the stock at the strike; the gain beyond that belongs to the buyer. If the price falls, the option expires, and the seller keeps the premium but bears the loss on the stock.
Most covered call ETFs sell one-month calls every month, often at the money, that is, with a strike close to the current price. For one month, with price S, strike K and premium C:
- price at the start and end of the month
- strike price of the call sold
- premium collected
Strike equal to the price at the start; premium of 2% assumed, before costs and dividends.
The chart shows the trade-off: when prices fall or move sideways, the covered call is ahead by the premium. When prices rise, the gain is capped at the premium, no matter how much the index rises.
The products differ in three respects. First, the underlying: calls on a volatile index such as the Nasdaq-100 bring higher premiums than on a broad index, because options there are more expensive. Second, the strike: at-the-money calls bring the highest premium and cap the most, calls a few percent above leave more room for gains. Third, the share written: some funds sell calls on only part of their holdings, say half, and keep full market participation for the rest. How much premium a fund collects also depends on market conditions. When the market expects large swings, options are expensive and premiums high; in calm times they are low.
Payout is not return
Covered call ETFs often advertise their distribution yield. It consists of dividends and option premiums and can be very high. What matters to the investor, though, is total return: distributions plus the change in the fund's price. Because the calls sold cap gains but not losses, the share price can fall over the years while the index rises. The high payout is then partly returned capital.
If you need regular income from your portfolio, you can also create it by selling shares of an ordinary index ETF. This homemade dividend keeps full participation in price gains and is often cheaper.
Where the return comes from
On average, options are slightly more expensive than the volatility that later materializes justifies. Whoever sells options earns this volatility risk premium, just as an insurer earns from premiums. Ilmanen (2012) found across many markets that selling insurance was rewarded in the long run, while buying catastrophe protection did poorly. The article on tail hedging covers the other side: whoever hedges pays it.
Whaley (2002) described the CBOE buy-write index, which holds the S&P 500 and sells an at-the-money call every month. For 1988 to 2001, the strategy did unusually well by several common measures, although its risk is hard to measure because of the skewed distribution. Israelov and Nielsen (2015) break covered calls down into three parts: equity risk, short volatility and a simple bet on price reversal. Equity risk delivers most of the risk and return. Short volatility achieved a Sharpe ratio close to 1.0 but contributed less than 10% of the risk. The reversal bet accounted for about a quarter of the risk and earned hardly any return.
Advanced: the hidden bet on reversal
Why does a bet on reversal arise? The delta of a covered call is 1 minus the delta of the call sold:
This suggests two adjustments. Calls further out of the money bring less premium but allow more price gains, and the delta changes less. And writing calls on only part of the holdings, say half, mixes the index with the covered call. Israelov and Nielsen (2015) propose a variant that keeps equity exposure stable and thus reduces the unrewarded reversal bet.
Covered call ETFs in a portfolio
- No substitute for bonds: Covered calls carry almost the full loss risk of stocks. In crashes they lose only the premium less.
- Less upside: In long bull markets they fall well behind. If you hold stocks mainly for their long-term return, you give part of it away.
- Costs: Covered call ETFs are usually more expensive than plain index ETFs, and trading options costs extra.
- Plan the payouts: If you depend on income, check whether distributions or selling shares is cheaper, also with a view to taxes.
Limitations and common mistakes
- Confusing distribution yield with total return: What counts is what is left after the price path and the payout.
- Short periods: A year of sideways markets makes the strategy shine, a strong year makes it look bad.
- Seeing high premiums as a gift: High premiums come when the market expects large swings, that is, when risk is high.
- Overlooking taxes: Distributions are taxed as they occur, price gains only when you sell.
How Portfolio Lab calculates
Under Asset classes there is the covered call S&P 500 (buy-write) series: a covered call ETF on the S&P 500, before that the CBOE buy-write index. Next to it is a put-write series with sold puts collateralized by money market securities. In the Backtest they can be compared directly with the S&P 500, including drawdown, volatility and skewness.
In the Option pricer tool you can assemble a covered call as a multi-leg strategy, view the payoff profile and value the premium with Black-Scholes or a binomial tree, also with the market's smile. How this is calculated is described in the option pricer methodology.
How a covered call would have done over many years is backtested by the Option strategies tool: it regularly sells calls on an underlying such as an S&P 500 ETF, prices them with Black-Scholes and the volatility of the VIX or the realized volatility, rolls them by fixed rules and deducts costs. The result sits next to buy-and-hold, with drawdown, the income from the options per year and the Greeks per month. The premiums are model prices, not quotes of traded options.
Frequently asked questions
What is a covered call ETF?
An ETF that holds stocks or an index and continuously sells call options on them, usually with one month to expiry. It pays out the premiums. In exchange, price gains are capped.
Why is the payout so high?
Because option premiums come on top of dividends. They are the price for the price gains given up. Total return is therefore usually not higher than the index's, and in strong bull markets clearly lower.
Are covered call ETFs safer than stock ETFs?
Hardly. They fluctuate a bit less because the premium cushions small losses, but they carry almost the full risk of large crashes.
When does a covered call strategy pay off?
In sideways or slightly falling markets it is ahead. In the long run it mainly earns the equity return and a volatility premium, but loses in strong bull markets.
Covered calls or selling shares?
If you need income, you can also regularly sell shares of an index ETF. This keeps full participation in price gains and is often cheaper. The best choice also depends on costs and taxes.
Literature
- Ilmanen, Antti (2012): Do Financial Markets Reward Buying or Selling Insurance and Lottery Tickets?. Financial Analysts Journal 68 (5), pp. 26–36. doi:10.2469/faj.v68.n5.7
- Israelov, Roni; Nielsen, Lars N. (2015): Covered Calls Uncovered. Financial Analysts Journal 71 (6), pp. 44–57. doi:10.2469/faj.v71.n6.1
- Whaley, Robert E. (2002): Return and Risk of CBOE Buy Write Monthly Index. The Journal of Derivatives 10 (2), pp. 35–42. doi:10.3905/jod.2002.319194
This article explains a method; it is not investment or tax advice. Worked examples are simplified and rounded. All terms in the glossary.